| 1966...............Finley Hayes | 1988................Thorie Finsrud | |
| 1967..............Henry Zender | 1989......Vernon 'Tiffy' Finsrud | |
| 1968...................Bob Zwick | 1990.............Stan Sygitowicz | |
| 1969................Frank Mullen | 1991......................Jed Davis | |
| 1970................Gabe Turner | 1992...................Bill Corning | |
| 1971................Eino Usitalo | 1993..................Vic Engholm | |
| 1972..................Baldy Clow | 1994..................Pete Zender | |
| 1973.....................Bob Gay | 1995...................Jim Cannon | |
| 1974..............Svend Larsen | 1996............Howard Hammer | |
| 1975..................Ted Strand | 1997....................Joe Zender | |
| 1976.................Lige Meece | 1998.....................Earl Quinn | |
| 1977................Lloyd Barter | 1999....Lawrence 'Red' Zender | |
| 1978.................Harry Scalf | 2000...........Sherman Ousdale | |
| 1979...............Glen Corning | 2001..................Archie Pullar | |
| 1980............Leo Sygitowicz | 2002...........George Eastwood | |
| 1981................Karly Larsen | 2003................Jerry Hammer | |
| 1982............Manny Van Dyk | 2004..............Howard Dorsey | |
| 1983.............Leroy Philliber | 2005...................Arnie Zwick | |
| 1984....Jack 'Big John' Zwick | 2006.....................Ed Maleng | |
| 1985..............Don Hamilton | ||
|
1986...............Abner Ludtke |
||
|
1987..............Lloyd Graham |