| 1963...................Finley Hays | 1985...................Gary Van Dyk | |
| 1964............Howard Hammer | 1986...................Gary Van Dyk | |
| 1965....................Earl Quinn | 1987......................Bob Larsen | |
| 1966...........Sherman Ousdale | 1988......................Bob Larsen | |
| 1967...................Bill Corning | 1989................Dan Williamson | |
| 1968....................Jack Zwick | 1990.................Ole Gunderson | |
| 1969..................Archie Pullar | 1991......................Arnie Zwick | |
| 1970...................Fred Gorum | 1992......................Arnie Zwick | |
| 1971...............Leroy Philliber | 1993......................Arnie Zwick | |
| 1972....................Joe Zender | 1994..................Frank Cain, Jr. | |
| 1973....................Jack Zwick | 1995.......................Bill Zender | |
| 1974.....................Ed Maleng | 1996.......................Bill Zender | |
| 1975...........George Eastwood | 1997....................Jeff Engholm | |
| 1976..............Brian Pederson | 1998....................Jeff Engholm | |
| 1977..................Bill Blockley | 1999..................Brett Engholm | |
| 1978...................Red Zender | 2000..................Brett Engholm | |
| 1979...................Red Zender | 2001..................Frank Cain, Jr. | |
| 1980............Steven Pederson | 2002...................Ryan Lenssen | |
| 1981..................Doug Barter | 2003...................Ryan Lenssen | |
| 1982............Lonny Schroeder | 2004...................Ryan Lenssen | |
| 1983..............Jim Williamson | 2005...................Ryan Lenssen | |
| 1984....................Earl Quinn | 2006.................Grant Pederson |